HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS SEARCH
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

 

Pie & Tart Crust Basics 

Page 2

ALL ABOUT INGREDIENTS

Page 1: Flaky & Sweet Crust Basics

#1: Measure & Prepare the Ingredients #2:  Add the fat #3: Sprinkle the ice water
#4: Form disk & chill #5: Roll  Mixing Problems  Rolling Problems

This Page: Flaky & Sweet Crust Basics

#6: Transfer  dough to pan #7: Finishing  touches #8: Blind-bake, moisture proof or use #9: Fill & bake or store / Pie crust problems & solutions

Page 3: Flaky & Sweet Crust Basics

Pie Dough Ingredients   Flute & Decorate Lattice Tops

Page 4: Flaky & Sweet Crust Basics 

Crumb Crusts Cookie Crusts Puff Pastry & Phyllo 

Pie Dough Recipes

When making a pie crust, ALWAYS THINK COLD for a flaky crust. The ingredients must be cold to start with and stay cold.

Basics #6:

TRANSFER AND FORM THE ROLLED DOUGH INTO THE PIE OR TART PAN: The goal is to first get it from the countertop to the pie pan, without tearing, and then, to EASE IT into place; do not force it otherwise it will shrink during baking. Correctly fitted dough stays put and has less of a chance of shrinking during baking. Dough can also be fitted into a heart or any-other-shaped pie pan. You do not have to prepare the pans in advance; because there is so much shortening in a piecrust, pans usually need not be greased or floured. 

FOR PIES & TARTS:

If dough is rolled in between two pieces of plastic wrap, skip #s 1 & 2, and go to #3, below.
FOR TARTS: 

Follow #s 1 - 4, to the left. Then, follow #s 5 - 9, below. (For small tarts, also check out additional tips).

Step 5: Working around the circumference of the pan, firmly press the dough into the fluting of the pan, gently pinching dough between forefinger and thumb and supporting the pan with the other hand as you go. 

Baking small tarts can be a pain; the dough shrinks and it takes time to fill each one with pastry weights before blind-baking. For tips, click here.

Step 6: Firmly run a rolling pin over the top of the pan, using the pan's sharp edges to trim off the excess dough. Refrigerate for 10 minutes before proceeding. 

Step 7: Chill the dough for 2 hours, preferably for up to 24 hours, before pre-baking or using.  The formed tart dough can also be frozen for future use.

Step 8: Tart shells can be blind-baked before filling.

Step #9: Fill the tart shell and bake.

1. Before transferring the rolled dough to the pie or tart pan, dust off the excess flour on the top, with a pastry brush or lightly with your fingertips; it will taste bitter after baking if you don't. You do not have to grease the pie or tart pans.

2. There are several ways to transfer the dough to the pie pan, however, in both cases make sure you do not stretch or tear the dough when doing so: Fold & Lift the Dough, Roll Dough Around a Rolling Pin, and Invert the Dough. 

If the dough cracks or breaks, it  may be too warm or too cold and can be patched. If the dough too cold, let it sit for a few minutes at room temperature before fixing it. If too warm, patch and re-chill the dough for an hour; don't wad it up, instead just chill as is. 

To patch: You can patch tears in pastry by moistening both sides of the crack, and without overlapping them, just pinch or press back together. Large gaps can be patched with trimmings cut from the overhanging dough. Dab water around the edges of the crack and apply a piece of the dough.  

The following three techniques can be used for both fitting pie or tart dough in their respective pans, but for also placing the top crust on a filled pie: 

FIRST WAY- FOLD & LIFT THE DOUGH: Using your dough scraper, or spatula, gently lift up the edges and fold it in half onto itself, and slide both hands underneath to support it.  Lift the dough and position the fold of dough over the center of the pie pan and let it rest on one side, draping over the edge. Carefully unfold it to cover the other side, and letting it drape over the side. If the dough is too warm and tears, place the as is on a cookie sheet, patch and chill. Take out of fridge and let it soften a bit, and try again. 

For a two-crust pie: To top pie, fold the dough in half, and carefully lift to the pie. Place the center of the fold over the center of the pie, with the top and bottom of the fold touching both edges of the pie. Unfold it, drape evenly over the filling, and trim. Then fold the edge of the top crust under the bottom crust and flute it closed with your thumb. Cut vents.

If using waxed paper or plastic wrap to roll your dough, lift off the top sheet, place a pan, up-side down, in the center of the dough. Slide your right (left) hand under the dough and plastic wrap, and place your left (right) hand on the bottom of the tin. Then,  quickly flip both over. Remove the now top piece of plastic wrap and allow the dough to ease into the pan.

SECOND WAY - ROLL DOUGH AROUND A ROLLING PIN: Some bakers roll the dough loosely onto a rolling pin, unless the dough is soft and sticky. To roll the dough onto the rolling pin, first place a floured rolling pin, centered on the edge nearest you. Roll away from you and at the same time pick up the edge (use a bench scraper or spatula if dough sticks to the countertop) and support the dough as you  wrap it around the pin, being careful not to press it. Keep rolling until all of the dough is rolled on the pin. Then, then drape the loose end over one edge of the pan and gently unroll, lowering it into the pan. 

For a two-crust pie: follow the steps right above for getting the top placed over the filling. Make sure it's evenly draped, and trim. Then fold the edge of the top crust under the bottom crust and flute it closed with your thumb. Cut vents.

Save leftover pie dough, wrap in plastic wrap, place in an airtight bag and freeze. When you need an instant topping for a baked fruit dish, grate the frozen dough over the top.

THIRD WAY - INVERT THE DOUGH: This technique can be used for both fitting pie or tart dough in their respective pans, but not for placing the top crust on a filled pie - If you have sticky dough from sugar, cream cheese, and/or eggs, the dough will be soft and sticky and difficult to get into the pan. So, you have to invert a pan and place it in the middle of the dough and flip both right side to, still attached to its bottom piece of waxed or plastic wrap. The easiest way to get the dough in the pan is to first remove the top layer of waxed paper or plastic wrap used when rolling it out. Place an inverted pie pan centered in the middle of it. Then, while holding one hand under the middle of the dough (palm side up), with the other inside the pie pan (palm side down), flip both over. The dough should be draped in the pan; do not press it in. Let the dough fall where it may and leave the waxed paper and plastic wrap; you will adjust it in the next step.

If part of the edge of the dough is too uneven, you can fix it. Roll or flatten a left-over piece, dot water where the "fix" will occur, and patch it onto the overhang by pressing lightly. This can be done preferably before or after trimming the dough. Then, roll it under and crimp as usual.

If the bottom dough cracks or tears in the pan, roll or flatten a small, left-over piece, dab a few drops of water on the crack and press the patch into place.

3.  After getting the dough in the pan, lift up the edges of the dough and carefully ease it down into the corners of the pan. Gently press it around the perimeter of the pie pan with the heal of your hand that is adjacent to your thumb so the dough adheres to the bottom of the pan; do not press too hard. Then, do the same on the sides of the pan, this time with your fingertips or the back of your forefinger. A small floured ball of dough also works; lightly press it against the dough in the pie pan. It is important to press lightly, as the dough will later shrink during baking if you do it too hard or stretch it. 

If you have a piece of waxed paper or plastic wrap attached, remove it by slowly peeling it off. If the dough is still too sticky or soft, refrigerate or quickly freeze both, and then afterwards, try and remove it again.

If making a rustic pie, don't trim the edges of the pie dough after placing in a pie pan. (I like to make mine in a pie pan because I find that it turns out better; they are usually baked flat on a baking pan and sometimes look too flat). Let the edges hang over the side while filling the pie. Then, fold them towards the center of the pie, so they drape over the filling. Before baking, brush crust with a mixture of 1 tablespoon each of milk and sugar. 

4.  Trim the excess dough around the edge of the pie using kitchen shears, which I find the easiest to use, or a sharp knife. Leave about an inch overhang for both a one-crust and a two-crust pie and 1/4-inch for a tart pan. (What to do with pie scraps.) 

FOR PIES: (For Tarts, see above).

5. One-Crust Pie:  Fold the excess dough underneath itself at the pie pan rim and even with the lip making a double layered edge. Go to Basics Step #7, below. 

For a Two-Crust Pie or Lattice Top: Chill the bottom pie crust for 1 to 2 hours, preferably 24, before filling. Skip Basics Step #s 7 & 8, and go to Basics Step #9.  

Basics #7:

PREPARE THE EDGES, TOPS AND / OR FINISHING TOUCHES:  For an empty single crust or a filled double crust pie that is ready to go. If a single crust, chill after fluting and before filling. It is not necessary to chill a double-crust pie again after fluting and before baking. 

Fluting provides several purposes: as decoration and to provide a double layer of dough at the rim to help prevent burning or overflow. One of the easiest decorative borders to make is using a fork to make slash marks along the edges. You can leave the border plain for a rustic look, or crimp or flute the border. For more, go to: "How to Make Decorative Edges & Tops".   

If desired, reroll the scraps, chill and cut out decorative designs such as leaves. First brush tops with egg wash (1 large egg beaten with 1 to 2 teaspoons water) or cream or half-and-half (milk will work, too, but the others are better). Bake on a small baking sheet at 400 degrees for 6 to 10 minutes or until golden brown. Remove to a rack to cool.

ALWAYS THINK COLD! Chill the dough, if a single crust pie, after forming it in the pie or tart pan, and after fluting, for 1 to 2 hours, preferably overnight before filling or blind baking.

Basics #8:

TO "BLIND BAKE" is to bake a single crust pie or tart, partially or fully, without fillings. Moisture-Proof a crust. (If not blind-baking, go to Basics Step #9.) Blind bake a crust after fluting and chilling, in Basics Step #7, above. If frozen, use directly; do not thaw.
Instead of using loose pastry weights, place them all in an oven-proof baking bag, used for baking meats with. This way you can put the entire bag in the unbaked pie or tart crust as one weight, filling it almost to the top. Make sure the tiny weights are evenly distributed thorough the inside of the crust and pressed against the sides. Then, when done, you can lift the entire bag out in one piece.

P.S. Sometimes I line my smaller pie or tart crusts with flat-bottomed coffee filters, and then fill with weights. It makes it easy to remove them all at once.

Alternative Weights - the heavier the better:  Use rice, dried beans, such as Navy, lentil or lima, or pastry weights available from a cookware store. Pennies make great weights because they are heavy. If using dried beans, cool them and store in the freezer between uses. They will not last indefinitely and turn rancid after several uses.

Blind baking refers to baking an unfilled pie or tart shell to produce a partially or fully baked crust.  It is done when making cream pies or tarts if a fillings is particularly moist or where precooked fillings are part of the recipe. However, it's necessary to weigh the crust down as it bakes, so it doesn't bubble up; you can do this in a variety of ways. It is done by lining the dough with parchment paper or foil and filling it with pie weights or dried beans to hold its shape during baking. Another option is to set a perforated pie pan into the crust.   You'll end up with bottom pan, pastry dough, then perforated pan on top). When using, be careful not to press it down around your decorated edge.

When the crust and filling bake together, some bakers make a practice of partially baking their crust, filling and then baking again. This prevents the crust from becoming soggy from custard based fillings, such as those with pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie and quiche. Partial blind baking can be done in a recipe such as a Lemon and Coconut Custard Pie. The crust is completely baked for recipes where the filling is made or cooked separately, such as with a Lemon Meringue Pie.

If bubbles form in the pie or tart shell during blind baking--air was trapped between the crust and the pan. Simply prick the bubbles during baking with the tines of a fork or the tip of a knife. To prevent it from happening in the future, prick the bottom before baking and use pie weights.

Empty pie shells need to be weighed down during baking. Without the weight of a filling, a pastry shell set into a hot oven can shrink dramatically, fill with air pockets, and puff up resulting in a shrunken uneven shell that looks unfinished. 

To prevent this the dough is lined, with my favorite, aluminum foil, filled with weights and then baked. Some bakers use parchment paper or waxed paper, but I like foil because you can press it right against the sides of the crust. In addition, foil promotes better heat conduction or a more even browning of the pastry, which parchment or waxed paper do not. 

You can use your pie crust shell right from the freezer, but it benefits from an overnight stay in the refrigerator before using. Time there helps to prevent pie crust shrinkage. Do NOT microwave to defrost.

When lining the pastry shell, leave an excess of foil on all sides so you can fold it over the pie edges to protect them from getting too brown when baked. Fill ALMOST TO THE TOP with pie weights, pennies, rice or dried beans to hold its shape during baking. Metal pie weights or pennies outperform rice and beans because they are heavier, and thereby better able to keep the shell from puffing. Also, being made of metal, they are better conductors of heat helping the crust to brown better. 

Remove the crust from the oven; if any parts of it have bubbled up, press them down gently.

Optionally, with partial or complete baking of the pie crust, the bottom of it can be moisture proofed. This is done by brushing with a glaze to seal it, five minutes before it is done and then afterward, returning it to the oven for 5 minutes more. You can also moisture proof right after baking. The pie shell is then thoroughly cooled on a wire cake rack before using in the recipe. It can be stored or frozen, if not.

HOW TO BLIND BAKE: Partially or Fully--Bake crusts in the lower third of the oven.
NOTE: Baking times are approximate. Watch your crust carefully as it will burn easily.
Partially Blind Bake

Many times bottom crusts will become soggy if filled with fruit or moist fillings. The solution is to  partially bake it first, then fill it and bake again.

You will bake it for about 20 minutes total, until golden brown, taking a couple of steps in between.

bulletPosition the oven rack in the lower third of the oven, place a baking sheet in the oven (the bottom of the pie crust will bake nicely when using) and preheat it to 425 degrees F for 20 minutes before baking.
bulletTake the well-chilled crust from the refrigerator or freezer. If the dough is not well-chilled, return it for 5 -10 minutes.
bulletFIRST BAKE FOR 8 - 10 MINUTES: Fill with pastry weights. First, cut a piece of parchment or waxed paper so it can reach up the sides of the pan. Place it in the chilled shell. Fill it 1/3 full with pie weights. Bake for 8 - 10 minutes with the beans or rice. 
bulletWhen done, remove crust and then remove the paper, rice or beans: carefully grab both sides of the parchment or waxed paper, and lift out the weights. Cool and return them to a jar.
bullet Reduce the oven heat to 350 degrees F
AND RETURN TO OVEN FOR 5 - 10 MINUTES (If optionally moisture-proofing, take from oven after 5 minutes)
bulletBAKE FOR ANOTHER 4 TO 5 MINUTES if moisture-proofing. Remove pie crust from oven or pull the oven's shelf out. Optionally, moisture proof the bottom of the crust with a moisture-proofing ingredient. Place pie shell in oven or push shelf back into the oven. Bake again for another 4 - 5 minutes, until the pie crust is starting to turn golden brown. 
bulletCool crust completely on a wire cake rack. 
bulletFill the crust and proceed to bake it as per the recipe, being careful the edges do not burn. Do not subtract the pre-baking time from the recipe's total.
Completely Blind Bake 

Done for tart shells and crusts where the filling is already cooked.

You will bake it for about 30 minutes total, until golden brown, taking a couple of steps in between. 

 

bullet Position the oven rack in the lower third of the oven, place a baking sheet in the oven (the bottom of the pie crust will bake nicely when using) and preheat it to 425 degrees F for 20 minutes before baking.
bulletTake the well-chilled crust from the refrigerator or freezer. If the dough is not well-chilled, return it for 5 -10 minutes.
bulletFIRST BAKE FOR 20 MINUTES: Fill with pastry weights. Cut a piece of parchment or waxed paper so it can reach up the sides of the pan. Place it in the chilled shell. Fill it 1/3 full with pie weights. Bake for 20 minutes with the beans or rice. When done, remove crust and then remove the paper, rice or beans: carefully grab both sides of the parchment or waxed paper, and lift out the weights. Cool and return weights to their container.
bullet Reduce the oven heat to 350 degrees F
AND RETURN TO OVEN
FOR 5 - 10 MINUTES (If optionally moisture-proofing, take from oven after 5 minutes): Prick (dock) the crust all over. Use the tines of a fork or docker. Return to the oven for 5 to 10 minutes more, until pale golden brown. The crust can release steam through the steam vents you created; if not, the pastry will buckle and bubble.   
bullet Pie Crust: Prick the bottom of the crust with the tines of a fork all over the bottom AND sides. 
bullet Tart Crust: Prick the bottom of the crust with the tines of a fork all over the bottom at 1/2 inch intervals. 
BAKE FOR ANOTHER 4 TO 5 MINUTES if moisture-proofing. Remove pie crust from oven or pull the oven's shelf out. Brush the bottom of the crust with a moisture-proofing ingredient if the precooked filling is particularly moist. 
Place pie shell in oven or push shelf back into the oven. 
When golden brown, remove crust to cool on a wire cake rack and then fill it. 
Do not bake again.

MOISTURE PROOF A CRUST: Many times, the bottom of a crust becomes soggy after filling and baking. To prevent this, you can moisture-proof the bottom of the pie crust.

Moisture-proof when partially or fully prebaking a crust:

bullet

Remove crust from oven when it has about 5 minutes left to bake. Apply moisture proofing with a pastry brush on the bottom of the crust and about an inch up the sides.

Moisture proof with:
bullet

1 large beaten egg or egg white (do not use butter as it contains water); or,

bullet

Warmed (not hot) and still thick corn syrup; or,

bullet

Sieved and warmed red currant jelly or an apricot glaze.

bullet

Bake for 4 to 5 minutes more to set the glaze and brown the crust. 

bullet

Then, remove from the oven and cool the crust thoroughly on a wire cake rack. Don't chill it afterwards; use or store at room temperature or freeze.

bulletFYI: Graham cracker crusts can be moisture-proofed with an egg wash.

Moisture-proof when fully prebaked:

bullet

Brush with melted chocolate or chocolate chips and let harden before filling.

bullet

Grate chocolate over the warm bottom of a fully baked or partially baked pie crust, and then spread it. As it melts, it makes a perfect and interesting moisture-barrier because it contains a lot of fat. Do not return the shell to the oven. Let it harden before filling.

bullet

Peanut butter (made with only peanuts and salt) would work the same way. Brush it on and fill pie shell.

bullet

For a quiche or savory pie, a Dijon mustard barrier works well. 

It can be difficult when blind baking a small tart shell or mini ones using a muffin tin or mini tart pan. The pastry dough's sides usually slump down and the bottom will puff as the fat melts, leaving you with shell that doesn't hold much or look appetizing.  Then I trim, prick extensively, place another pan or on top and bake. During baking, the crust won't slide down into itself, and the top pan holds the dough down and prevents excess puffing. 

To solve this problem, I let gravity help me. What I do is to turn the pie pan upside down, place pastry over the outside and delicately press it into the pan. Then I trim, prick it extensively all over, which prevents the bottom from puffing up, or the sides from slumping down as the fat melts. Before baking, I also fit another pastry pan (the same size) over the pastry dough. Do not squish the pie crust dough when doing so. If the fit is too tight, instead, cover the crust with a criss-cross of foil. Use several pieces that are large enough to be tucked under the rim. Center the foil over the bottom of the pastry dough, press it into the dough on its top and sides, tuck it under the rim of the pie or tart pan or muffin tin. A parchment circle between the spare pan and the crust bottom makes them easier to separate, but it's not necessary. It works well every time, even with regularly sized pies.

If you want to flute the edges, leave an excess of pastry dough, prick all over and place another pan on top. Flip both pans over at the same time. With the excess dough, flute the edges. When you bake the pie crust, to keep the fluting from crushing, center it upside down over an upside down Pyrex bowl or any heat proof container in the oven. (Preheat the oven with the bowl or container centered on a lower shelf. When ready to bake, carefully position the pie tin over it.)  

Basics #9:

BAKING THE UNBAKED OR PARTIALLY BLIND BAKED PIE CRUST WITH A FILLING. If you have fully baked the crust in advance, do not bake the filled pie or tart again, so skip this step. Another option besides baking, is to store the pie shell. 
There are several options when topping a pie or tart with fruit: 
bulletWhen topping with fruit, always work from the outside in - arranging fruit from the outside edge and working towards the center. You want the center to be the highest point.
bulletAnother technique is to simply mound the fruit attractively in the shell. 

If not baked or partially baked, to ensure that a crust bakes on the bottom, the following tips really help. By working with oven temperatures, a baking sheet and baking your pie on the lowest rung, you should have good results.

Dear Sarah, I tried your recipe for "Classic Peach Pie", the only thing I didn't have was the nutmeg whole to grate, (so I) used... powdered. I have to tell you the pie was OUTSTANDING!! Starting the pie at a much higher temperature, dropping it down, and not opening the oven, seemed to give the bottom the cooked flakiness... there was no doughy wet stuff at the bottom (that always happens)... when I tried to use flour as a thickener. It wasn't soupy either, it was perfect. Thank you so much, and I love your site. nrainy49, Ask Sarah, 12-22-00

PREHEAT THE OVEN: Pies are baked at higher temperatures (375 to 450 degrees F) than cakes bake at, so the rich pastry dries and becomes flaky and golden brown and the filling cooks all the way through.

You will bake your pie, for example, in a well preheated oven (450 degree F is best) in the middle of the shelf in the lower third of the oven or on its floor. (You will lower the heat to 350 degrees F when placing the pie in the oven). This allows for the bottom to cook thoroughly before the top crust browns. Convection ovens also work well as they circulate the hot air. As a rule of thumb, lower the temperature given in most recipes by 25 degrees F, as these ovens tend to bake hotter and quicker.

I like to bake my pies on a pizza stone to improve the bottom crust. Because I don't own a pizza stone, I purchased four 9-inch unglazed quarry tiles at Home Depot (for about 55 cents apiece) and used them. I preheated them on the bottom rack of the oven for about 30 minutes. 

Before preheating, I also placed the pie on a sheet of heavy-duty foil set on the tiles to catch drips. Rather than try to make and fit a foil ring for the pie edge and to keep the fluted edge from overbrowning, I simply lifted the foil up and around the pie edges for the last minutes of baking. The bottom crust browned beautifully.

The intense heat is necessary for ending up with a perfectly baked and flaky pie crust, provided it is mixed, rolled and chilled adequately. In this way, the water quickly evaporates from pie and crust, allowing the crust to set faster than the fat melts. This way the the air-pockets are well-defined, created where the fat once was before it melts away, thus giving you a flakiness when you bite in into it.

There are a couple of things to prepare in advance: Before preheating the oven, adjust the oven shelf to the lowest rung and place a  foil covered pizza stone or a baking sheet on it.  Both do a good job with baking and browning the bottom crust, although the pizza stone does it best.  (If the pie crust top needs browning during baking, place it on the top shelf for the last 10 minutes of baking.) If using a pizza stone, preheat the oven for about 30 minutes so the tiles heat up.

Many times, a fruit pie will bake and there will be a space left between the filling and the top crust. Try The Ultimate Apple Pie Recipe where it doesn't happen; I used apples apples that work better than others for fillings. 

With apple pies, you want to build up the filling to look like a mound. The way spaces happen are as an apple softens during cooking, steam is released. Steam collects beneath the top crust, where it then expands and rises in a hot oven, causing pressure from beneath that supports the crust until it sets in the oven. Meanwhile, the apples inside have collapsed to form a filling. The right apples won't do that.   

When you have extra pie filling, freeze an extra batch in an aluminum foil pie pan. Then, when you need a pie, just thaw the filling slightly and lower the whole thing into a dough-lined pie pan. Cover with top crust or streusel and bake.

When filling, there are a couple of types of pie crust shells you will use: chilled and not baked, or partially or fully blind-baked. Add it after the crust has chilled or cooled. If you fill a pie or tart shell with a moist filling, it will soak and soften the crust if not baked right away. This will also happen even if the crust is partially prebaked in Basics Step #8, so get it into the oven fast !!

Before filling the pie, protect the edges from over-browning: center the pan in a long criss-cross of foil and fill.  Right before baking, gather the foil around the pie pan, bringing it up and around its edges. There are also pie crust shields you can use. It is easier to do in advance of baking rather than taking the pie out of the oven halfway through and trying to cover the crust without burning yourself.

CHILLED PIE CRUST, NOT BAKED:

One-Crust

For one-crust pies that bake the filling in the shell, such as pumpkin and pecan pies, don't prick the crust. If you do, the filling will seep under the crust during baking.

Fill fluted pie shell to be baked almost to the rim, leaving an 1/8-inch between the top of the filling and the pie crust rim. 

I have often filled Pumpkin Pies too much and I always spill some when placing in the oven -- oh well ! (The way around it is to preheat the oven with a baking sheet on the appropriate shelf, pull it out and place the pie pan on it. Then fill the pie and push the shelf back in).

After filling the single crust pie, moisten the rim with egg wash before baking.  

Two-Crust

Fill bottom and chilled pie crust. After filling, take the top-crust dough from the refrigerator, and roll out the second crust or prepare the lattice crust. After rolling the top crust, fold the top crust dough in half, center it on top of the filling and unfold. Tuck the edge of it under the edge of the bottom crust. 

Apply the finishing touches, such as fluting.  

BLIND-BAKED (PREBAKED) PIE CRUST:

Partial

Fill pie or tart shell and then, bake.

Full

Fill pie or tart shell and do not bake again. When assembling baked tart shells, first unmold it from the tart pan (don't unmold a fully baked pie shell). After the tart shell has completely cooled, do so by pushing up the bottom and releasing the side. Slide a metal spatula or knife between the tart pan bottom and the tart to loosen it. 

Slide the tart shell onto a flat plate or or flat cake platter (do not use one with sides; the tart shell will break). Then, fill.

If filled with custard or moist fillings, make sure you moisture-proof the bottom and assemble as close to serving time as possible to avoid soggy pastry.

Sometimes you end up with extra filling and pie scraps. With Apple Pie, for example, eat the extra apples or make a small amount of applesauce. Bake the pie scraps separately. You can also make mini-pies. Save the filling and make another pie or tart crust, depending on how much you have. To store any perishable fillings, cover and refrigerate right away.

I make mini-pies with the extra pie crust scraps and filling in my greased muffin tins or custard cups (fill the unused cavities 1/2 full with water). For the bottom of the pie, I cut it from rolled pie dough with a round cookie cutter, slightly larger than the size of the bottom of one of the tin's cavities. (To get the right size, place the tin on a piece of paper and trace around one of them). Then, I center the dough over the cavity and gently guide it  to the bottom. Here, I lightly press it into place, as well as slightly up the sides to form a crust. I then fill and bake my mini-pies at the same temperature as the recipe, but for less than half the time.

Another way is to fit the dough over an inverted muffin tin. Weigh the crust down with another pan placed on top or wrap tightly in foil wrap. Prick the crust all over before baking.

BAKE: The oven should be preheated oven to 450 degrees F as measured with an oven thermometer. Make sure the pizza stone or baking sheet has a chance to get hot before placing the cold pie on top, which takes about 30 minutes (don't let the pie sit out if the oven is not ready -- refrigerate it covered, not matter what type you have).  

For certain juicy pies (peach, nectarine, raspberry), bake the pie directly on the floor of the oven for a truly crispy bottom crust. Put a piece of foil down first to catch any drippings.

Place the pie in the oven and immediately lower the heat to 350 degrees F. It will take the oven about 20 minutes to lower in temperature, and continue to bake it. Don't open the oven for 40 minutes. 

I got the sheen and the crisp, sweet top crust I wanted by brushing the pastry with egg white and sprinkling it with sugar if  I waited 20 minutes into the baking process. I discovered that it mattered when the pie got this "egg wash." If I applied it before baking, the fluting tended to bloat, losing the crisp, distinct shape. But when I applied it later, the pastry held its shape.

I would check the pie after about 45 minutes, then use your eyes to judge when it's done. Take pie or tart out when it has browned on top.  

If the top of the pie is browning too much, tent it with foil, but be sure to make a steam hole in the center for moisture to escape so the crust stays crisp.

For a juicy fruit pie, the crust should be golden brown and juices from the filling should be thick with a slow bubble. For an apple pie the crust will be golden and the apples tender when a small knife is inserted.

Custard pies are done when a knife inserted in the middle comes out clean. Be careful that the top does not burn.

When done, cool completely on a wire cake rack before serving. Allow the pie to cool on a rack to room temperature, or until barely warm, before slicing to ensure that the filling is set and will not run. This holds especially true for pie with fruit fillings. Cooling will take between 2 to 4 hours for a fruit pie, depending on its thickness. For a custard pie, let cool and chill immediately. Serve or store after baking.

Reheating Instructions:
In the oven: Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Place whole uncovered pie (or remainder) on a baking sheet in center of oven for approximately 15 minutes, until warmed to the touch.
In the Microwave: Remove portion of the pie you want to heat, from the pie tin and place on microwaveable container. Heat one slice approximately 20 seconds, or until just warmed.

PIE CRUST TROUBLESHOOTING:
Crust loses shape--When going into the oven, the crust wasn't cold enough, and the oven wasn't hot enough.
Crust burned in spots--The crust's rollout wasn't even.
Crust shrinks--Gluten has developed making the dough elastic, usually because of over mixing but sometimes because of excessive rolling. If there is too little shortening, or if the ingredients are too warm or if there is too much water, shrinking will also occur. Chilling the dough after rolling it out, but before baking, will help to prevent shrinking. Roll the pastry to an even thickness and don't stretch pastry when transferring it to pie pan.
Edges fell over while baking--Usually the crust is too thick and falls over because of its own weight. However, too high a proportion of fat in the recipe, under mixing, or placing warm dough in the over to bake before it has been chilled will also contribute to this problem.
Crust tough--Sometimes there is not enough fat in the recipe which allows too much gluten to develop. Overworking the dough also makes it tough. When a crust is served cold it will often be tough because the fat is chilled, making the crust hard.
Pastry is crumbly and hard to roll--Measure your ingredients carefully. Too much shortening makes the pastry crumbly. Add more water, 1 teaspoon at a time.
Soggy bottom crust--Could be one of several things. Check out your pie pan. Glass, dark metal and dull-metal pans absorb heat and produce a crisp, golden-brown crust. Filling leakage could also cause a soggy crust. Patch any cracks with a pastry scrap and with a little water so it stays in place. Also make sure your oven temperature is accurate. If the temperature is too low the crust won't brown properly. After baking, cool your pie on a wire rack. Allowing the air to circulate under the pie prevents the crust from becoming soggy. You could have used too much lard, shortening, or butter in the recipe. Ingredients were not cold enough during preparation. You could have overworked the crust.. The fillings could have been a bit too runny.
Pie crust burns around the edges--To prevent overbrowning of the fluted edge of your pie, make a shield by cutting a strip of aluminum foil 2 inches wide and 3 inches longer than the diameter of your pie pan. When the crust begins to brown, place the foil over the pie, gently curving the foil to cover the fluted edge.
Tough pastry--Use a pastry blender to cut in the shortening until well mixed and the mixture resembles small peas. It's the tiny pockets of fat encased in flour that make a pie crust crisp. Use less flour when rolling out the pastry since too much flour and too much water makes pastry tough.

  Go BACKWARDS, or forwards to Pies & Tarts, page 3.

up arrowup arrow

HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS BAKING TIPS
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

© baking911.com, Inc., 2000- 2008. Founded October, 2000. All Rights Reserved. All material on baking911.com's web pages is the express opinion of its authors. baking911.com is not responsible for any direct, incidental, consequential, indirect or punitive damages arising out of its pages or those accessed through this Site. baking 911 is a registered trademark and "bake like a pro" is a trademark of Sarah Phillips
~ Order my cookbooks ~ Baking 9-1-1 and The Healthy Oven Baking Book  ~ Recipe Fixes