HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS SEARCH
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

 

Cake  Types

The easiest way to compare cake types is to look at this chart. It's interesting to see how the different cakes compare have also included some valuable tips when making them. (For more). 

~ Cakes fall into two major groups, foam cakes (little or no fat) and shortened (butter) cakes. ~ 

Cakes that do not contain fat, such as sponge, angel food and chiffon cakes, are often referred to as foam cakes. These have a larger proportion of egg than butter cakes. 

Butter cakes, also called creamed cakes, contain butter, margarine or vegetable shortening, which contribute to a finely textured, tender and moist cake. 

Both foam and butter cakes lend themselves to limitless variations, depending on the flavorings added to the basic ingredients, the shapes of the pans used in baking, and fillings, icings and decorations used. 

Foam Cakes: High ratio of eggs to flour and fall into three categories.
#1: No Fat:
Dacquoises
#2: Only Fat is Egg Yolk:
#3: Oil and Fat in Addition to Egg Yolks: 
Shortened Cakes: Contain fat, frequently in a solid form, and a high ratio of eggs to flour.
The easiest way to compare cake types is to look at this chart. It's interesting to see how the different cakes compare:
PERCENTAGES OF MAJOR INGREDIENTS IN BASIC CAKE TYPES:
CAKE TYPE:  % LIQUID % EGG % FLOUR % SUGAR % FAT
Angel Food 6 47 13 34 0
Sponge 4 45 20 31 0
Biscuit Roulade* 0 59 14 27 0
Chiffon 14 35 18 24 9
Genoise* 0 46 23 23 8
Basic Butter 24 10 27 27 12
Pound 12 22 22 22 22
Pancakes 52 20 23 0 5
Chart from THE CAKE BIBLE, by Rose Levy Beranbaum, William Morrow, 1988 *w/o syrup

MORE ABOUT FOAM & SHORTENED CAKES:

(General Cakemaking Tips)

FOAM CAKES: Strictly speaking, a foam cake contains no leavening or fat other than provided by the eggs; baking powder and baking soda are not necessary in these recipes. As a result, it is important to preheat the oven and have the baking pans ready in advance. These cakes need to be baked as soon as they are ready or the egg whites will deflate; they will do so after about 5 minutes of sitting on the countertop ! Because Foam Cakes are so light and airy, they should be cut with a serrated knife in a sawing motion to cut. An electric knife is helpful, too.

There are some similarities and differences within Foam Cakes:

Sponge cakes are a light cake whose leavening comes only from beaten egg whites (no baking powder or soda), and has little or no butter and thus have very little fat content. As a result, a Sponge cake takes well to being imbibed with flavored syrups and such. 

There are essentially two varieties of sponge cakes, the Biscuit and the Genoise: 

bullet

The Biscuit is where the eggs are separated and the yolks whipped with sugar until pale yellow while the whites are whisked with a little sugar until voluminous. Then the two are folded together with a bit of flour to bind them and, if desired, melted butter and or a flavoring like vanilla are added last. Then there is the classic genoise sponge cake. 

bullet

In a Genoise the eggs are beaten whole--never separated--with the sugar, until they are mousse-like and very pale yellow. Last, the flour is folded in as well as vegetable oil or clarified butter for moistness. The butter makes a moister, more tender and flavorful cake.

Chiffon cakes are light like sponge cakes, but are easier to make because there are no egg whites to beat and fold in. Plus, there’s more fat in it (oil) so it’s more tender and moist than sponge cake. 

Angel food cakes have no added leavening (such as baking powder), shortening or egg yolks. They are leavened with beaten egg whites and they have a high proportion of them to flour. Angel food cakes make a fabulous no-fat treat.

SHORTENED CAKES VS FOAM CAKES:

SHORTENED CAKES:

FOAM CAKES:

Review mixing techniques: different methods produce different types of cakes

One of the most important steps is to properly cream the fat with the sugar. This is when air bubbles are formed, which will later expand from the leaveners, and make the cake rise.

There are two primary types of foam cakes - whole egg yellow sponge and angel food cake. An angel food cake is a meringue with added flour for stability and texture. Egg white proteins and the starch and protein of flour are incorporated into the watery film around air cells to contribute to stability. Sugar is added not only for its flavoring action and stabilizing effect on egg white proteins, but it also acts as a tenderizer, counterbalancing the effects of egg protein and flour. Cream of tartar is usually added to lower the pH and thus stabilize and whiten the foam and produce a finer grained cake. Leavening is performed by the air in the meringue and steam. Ingredients are folded together gingerly. Old genoise recipes call for melting butter and folding into the batter.  Angel Food recipes have you fold the sifted flour into the beaten egg whites.

Pay attention to the specified ingredient  temperatures: 

Recipes will specify room temperature butter and other ingredients, which is very important.  Having the ingredients at approximately the same temperatures helps make a consistent creamed mixture which holds air well and incorporates the dry ingredients easily. This helps create a batter that rises evenly. A mixing bowl right from the dishwasher will melt the fat or "cook" the eggs, so make sure that it, too is at room temperature. I like to use an Instant Read Thermometer to help me through recipes.

A recipe will say sometimes say "whip the egg whites" or "beat the yolks" and does not specify at what temperature. It is important in general and makes a big difference when making foam cakes. These cakes rely upon eggs and/or yolks for their leavening. The maximum amount of air can be beaten into them when at room temperature which means a higher and more tender cake. When sugar is added to Angel Food Cakes, it should be gradual  while beating egg whites at room temperature.

Some cake recipes will also direct you to beat egg yolks with sugar (click  for the best way). 

Use the right ingredients & pans:

Superfine sugar is recommended because it dissolves quickly and makes finer textured cakes.

The right equipment and pans are key.   

Superfine sugar is recommended because it dissolves quickly and makes finer textured cakes.

The right equipment and pans are key. Chiffon Cakes can be typically baked in a tube pan, as with Sponge Cakes. The cake should turn out like a large and puffed-up "life-saver" shape. Chiffon Cakes, however, can also be baked as a layer cake.

Bake until done: 

The test for doneness is when the sides shrink from the pans and when lightly touched in the middle, the cake springs back.

My favorite way to cool a Angel Food or a Chiffon Cake is to place the pan upside in a colander. The holes allow the cake to cool properly and it is certainly more stable than trying to balance it over the neck of a bottle. Also, I find that the upside-down warm cake top condenses when supported by the pan legs. They're short and bring the cake too close to the countertop where moisture accumulates from the warmth. 

Remove the cake from the oven when it is absolutely done. If not, the fragile batter will collapse. It is ready when the edges shrink from the sides or the pan and it springs back when touched in the center of the batter. (The centers are found around the cake ring).

Always cool baked goods thoroughly:

Butter cakes can be cooled in their pans or removed and then cooled. When a cake is cooled completely in its pan it should be placed on a wire cake rack. If unmolding, the finished cake should first sit on the rack in the pan for 10 minutes. The cake is then removed and put back on the rack right-side-up to cool completely.   

Foam cakes must be turned upside down to cool while still in their pans. The fragile cake structure would collapse if not. Placing it this way allows the warm cake to stretch and set before turning it right-side-to when cool. Some place the upside-down-pan on four inverted drinking glasses or set in a colander, which I prefer. 

MORE CAKE TYPES:

Charlottes: These molded desserts are a variation of the cake in which fillings - hot or cold - are poured into a bowl lined with bread, ladyfingers or pieces of cake, then decorated. A French pastry chef invented the charlotte in the 1800s. The classic version is the Charlotte Russe. Also try such flavors as chocolate, eggnog, strawberry, Bavarian cream.

Meringue cakes: Made from beaten egg whites and sugar, meringue is used as a leavening agent in some cake batters or to lighten a souffle or mousse. Baked by themselves into rings or other shapes, meringues make for light and pretty cakes filled with fruit or ice cream. They can be family size or baked as individual servings.

Rolls: These are a form of sponge-cake, baked in a shallow pan and used for jellyrolls or such holiday cakes as the Christmas "yule log," an especially nice variation. Rolls are immediately removed from the pan and rolled up in a sugared tea towel after baking. When cool, they are unrolled gently, filled with jelly, custard or icings and rerolled. For the yule log (Buche de Noel), fill and ice with chocolate buttercream, then decorate with leaves, "branches," meringue mushrooms and woodland animals - a crowd-pleaser!

up arrowup arrow

HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS BAKING TIPS
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

© baking911.com, Inc., 2000- 2008. Founded October, 2000. All Rights Reserved. All material on baking911.com's web pages is the express opinion of its authors. baking911.com is not responsible for any direct, incidental, consequential, indirect or punitive damages arising out of its pages or those accessed through this Site. baking 911 is a registered trademark and "bake like a pro" is a trademark of Sarah Phillips
~ Order my cookbooks ~ Baking 9-1-1 and The Healthy Oven Baking Book  ~ Recipe Fixes