|
|
Cheesecakes
are of America's most favorite desserts. Everybody has
his favorite ranging from the purist's choice which is dense and creamy called a
NY Style Cheesecake
or
Junior's Famous No. 1
Strawberry Cheesecake Recipe
to light and airy as in my
Reduced-Fat Chocolate
Cheesecake.
You can bake your own or purchase one
ready-made from the frozen food section of the supermarket or
online.
From:"chris" via email
To: sarah@baking911.com
Subject: Cheesecake troubleshooting
Date:Sun, 27 Nov 2005 18:40:22 -0800
I was looking for some helpful hints on the
art of baking cheesecakes and was sent this site with all the hints one
could ever imagine!! I feel much better after reading that a cheesecake
just might crack and it will still taste great. I have a little bit of
confidence in trying one now!!
I am sending this site to my sister.
What a wonderful baking site!
Thanks!
|
Though a cheesecake can be savory
(and served with crackers as an appetizer), most of us think of the term as
describing a luscious, rich dessert. The texture of any cheesecake can vary
greatly-from light and airy to dense and rich to smooth and creamy depending on
the ingredients and mixing methods used. It is really a
baked custard and needs to be treated
as such. Just as most
baked products are essentially flour protein structures, custards are egg
protein structures.
I have included all sorts of information about
making your own cheesecake, from its ingredients, how to mix, how long to bake
and serving tips. My tips will hopefully come in handy helping to prevent the #1
problem most of us bakers have, which is a
cracking cheesecake or one that
puffs up in the oven and falls
during baking. I will also show you how to
prevent water from leaking into the pan
when placed in a waterbath, how to
remove the springform pan's bottom, storage tips and of course, lots of
cheesecake recipes!
What is
a Cheesecake?:
Cheesecakes comprise two or
three components: a
crust, sometimes prebaked, the filling and optionally a topping layered in a
special Springform Pan and
baked with or without a waterbath. After baking, cheesecakes must be chilled a
few hours, preferably overnight, in order to gel.
All dessert cheesecake fillings
begin with a
soft cheese
- usually cream cheese, but it can
contain mascarpone, cottage cheese, farmer
cheese, Neufchatel, ricotta, goat cheese or
yogurt cheese,
cottage cheese or sometimes Swiss or cheddar cheese if savory.
For
a thick cheesecake recipe, baked in an 8- or 9-inch Springform or a 9- x
2-inch cake pan, look for recipes that contain 2 pounds (4, 8-ounce packs)
of creamcheese. |
A classic cheesecake
filling is made by creaming the cheese and mixing it with sugar (for desserts),
eggs, and vanilla extract or other flavorings
such as chocolate, peppermint, mocha, lemon, cherry and more.
The
Pumpkin Cheesecake
is one of my favorites. Add-ins,
such as chocolate chips or chopped candy
can be folded into the batter before
baking, as in the
Peppermint Candy
Cheesecake Recipe.
Sometimes a starch, such as
cornstarch or flour
are added to the cheesecake's ingredients, such as in the
Junior's Famous No. 1
Strawberry Cheesecake Recipe.
These recipes will result in a cheesecake
whose texture is slightly more firm and dense. These flour-containing
cheesecakes can be baked directly on the oven rack at moderate temperatures, but
sometimes you will see them baked in a waterbath, which is a gentler heat.
Cheesecake recipes that do not contain flour are intended to be delightfully
smooth and silky, such as the
NY Style Cheesecake.
To achieve the proper texture, these
cheesecakes must be baked in a waterbath at a lower temperature.
A cheesecake may or may not have
a crust and they vary. Crusts can be a light dusting of cookie crumbs or the
classic Graham
Cracker Crust, made from just graham cracker crumbs, sugar and
butter. Some crust recipes use a combination of
chopped nuts and cookies are used, such as in the
White Chocolate, Macadamia
Nut Cheesecake Recipe. A Pound cake
crust is used to make the
Tiramisu Cheesecake Recipe.
Even a Sponge cake bottom can be
found in
Junior's Famous No. 1
Strawberry Cheesecake Recipe. Or,
no crust at all, such as in the
Meyer Lemon Cheesecake Roulade.
After the crust is made and pressed
into the bottom of a Springform pan, it is sometimes prebaked. The batter is
poured on top of the crust and baked (again). When done, a perfectly baked
cheesecake will be puffed around the edges, yet the center should be slightly
moist and will jiggle. Look around the edge you'll see tiny cracks that look
dry. When it cools, those tiny cracks will seal together. Cheesecakes become
firmer as they cool and before serving, they must be refrigerated for 8 hours or
more, preferably overnight.
Right after baking or after being
chilled, cheesecakes can be
topped by varied choices as sour cream,
raspberry, strawberry, praline and streusel, such as in the
Classic Cheesecake
Recipe. Toppings also
include whipped cream, fruit or even chocolate ganache. A cheesecake's edge may
be trimmed with crust or cookie crumbs pressed into it. On top of that, some
even frost theirs, such as in the
White Chocolate -
Frosted Hazelnut Cheesecake with a Raspberry Garnish (phew!) Recipe.
Many home-cooks are often a little
nervous about diving into baking a cheesecake. We’ve all heard how temperamental
they can be and how they must be perfect, without cracking, falling, being
lopsided, dry, uneven browning, no browning or looking inedible. The best part
about a cheesecake is that you can hide any imperfections under a disguise of a
topping or serve it by cutting around its cracks as long as it tastes good. To
be on the safe side, choose a cheesecake recipe that has a topping, such as the
Classic Cheesecake Recipe.
My first cheesecake attempts looked
so horrible, but tasted great. So, I cut it into chunks and served them in a
parfait dish, with a spoonful of blueberry compote and whipped cream. No one
knew and thought that I had invented a new cheesecake dessert! (This is also a
good way to serve it when you drop the cheesecake on the floor, which I have
done before!) Or, maybe you'd like to follow my lead and serve your
cheesecake anyway, cracks and all!
Regardless of the type of cheesecake you prefer,
here are a few secrets to preparing and baking it like a pro. Once you get the
hang of it, I know that you will end up with a moist and good-looking
cheesecake, that's also quite delicious!
Remember, it's essential to bake your cheesecake at least one day before you
plan to serve it so it can chill and firm up in the refrigerator
for at least 8 to 12 hours, preferably overnight.
|
Ingredients |
If you can, use full-fat ingredients, such as cream cheese, because it
will produce a creamy texture. ~ I use Philadelphia
brand cream cheese which gives the most traditional flavor and best
results. It is the best and works EVERY time, so I can't recommend any
other kind ~ Don't use the fat free kind because the cheesecake
will be chalky and slightly rubbery inside. Instead, the reduced-fat type,
often dubbed "Neufchatel", is the one I use and will yield a better
cheesecake if you are watching you weight.
(Check out my
Reduced-fat Cheesecake Recipe) ~
If you wish, you can use
"natural" cream cheese without any gums or stabilizers; the flavor is
superior, but the texture of the cheesecake will be drier, and creaminess
is the goal here. ~ Use heavy
cream, pasteurized rather than ultra pasteurized, and full-fat sour cream.
If watching your weight, light (reduced-fat) sour cream works the best.
~ Use the egg size specified. If none is specified,
use large (not jumbo or extra-large) ~ Don't lower the amount of sugar.
Sugar in
a "custard mixture", such as a cheesecake, breaks up the clumps of protein
molecules so that they are finely dispersed in the liquid mixture. The
temperature at which the custard sets is thus raised, permitting the egg
proteins to coagulate slowly and enmesh the other ingredients, resulting
in a smooth, stable consistency.~
For a fluffier cheesecake, separate the eggs and mix yolks into the cream
cheese mixture, beat whites till soft peaks and lastly blend into the
mixture. |
|
Pans |
A cheesecake is typically baked in a 9 or
10 inch springform pan, a
round pan with high, straight sides, about 2-1/2 to 3 inches high.
The separate bottom of the
pan can be removed from the sides when the clamp is released. This allows
the cheesecake to be extricated easily by simply removing the pan's sides.
Usually cheesecake mixtures should fill
the pan almost full or at least more than half way. However, you can bake
cheesecakes in smaller pans or make mini ones
baked in muffin tins, lined with muffin cups.
I like to use a
solid one-piece cake pan
when baking a cheesecake in a waterbath. It doesn't leak as a springform
pan usually does, even if you wrap in foil.
Any
pan you use, brush the sides and the bottom of the pan or muffin cups with
melted butter so when the cheesecake cools the cake can release from it
without splitting. Make sure you get the corners and the walls all the way
to the top. I even place a piece of parchment or waxed paper in the bottom
for easy removal. Grease after placing on top if you do. |
|
Crust Making |
Crusts are strictly optional, but add so
much to any cheesecake recipe.
(cookie or graham cracker crusts or even a sponge cake layer base) If you
don't use any crust, remember the cheesecake will bake in less time since
crusts act as insulators.The pressed
or crumb crusts under which cheesecakes are built on are actually
no-brainers, as in the
Graham
Cracker Crust Recipe. All you
need is some crushed cookies or graham crackers (I'd say about 33 of them
to be exact), sometimes sugar and melted butter and stir thoroughly just
to get everything moistened. The secret for prepping this crust is that
you don't want to chop these up too fine. You want to crush them by hand.
Sure you could do it in a food processor but it would be way too even. You
want to end up with lots of pieces the size of small pebbles integrated
with a lot of little bitty crumbs. In order for this loose amalgam of
crumbs is going to come together to form a cohesive crust, you need to add
a little bit of pressure; when making the crust, sprinkle the crumbs on
the bottom of the pan so that none of it shows. Then, pack it down firmly
with the bottom of a glass or a metal measuring cup. Have the crust go up
the sides about a 1/4-inch. This is especially important when baking a
cheesecake in a springform pan; it helps block the batter from leaking out
the bottom edge of the pan. If not prebaking your crust, place in fridge
for 1/2 hour before using. If prebaking, called blind baking, let cool
before adding the cheesecake mixture, unless otherwise directed.
|
|
Use ingredients at room
temperature and do not overbeat --
what you want to avoid in any cheesecake making step is to beat air into
the mixture. Too
much air will make the cheesecake fall.
During baking these air bubbles expand, but since there is no flour to
support them they burst upon cooling and the center collapses as all
soufflés do eventually. |
|
HOW
TO GET ROOM TEMPERATURE CREAMCHEESE: It takes regular cream
cheese about three to four hours to come to room temperature (68 - 70
degrees), reduced-fat about an hour and a half.
However,
creamcheese is perishable, so I wouldn't leave it out of refrigeration
for that long. To bring cream cheese to room temperature, quickly,
place completely unwrapped package(s) in a microwaveable bowl.
Microwave on HIGH for 30 to 45 seconds or until slightly softened --
Do NOT let it melt or get warm. Refrigerate if it does. |
For the filling, in the bowl of a
heavy-duty standing mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the room
temperature creamcheese and sugar on LOW SPEED .
Scrape the sides of the bowl frequently with a
rubber spatula so all amounts reach the beaters. If
the batter is lumpy,
let it sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes and squish the lumps
with the back of a wooden spoon on the side of the bowl.
Mix briefly to
incorporate.
If the batter still has lumps,
do not mix any more and strain through a large strainer and stir to
incorporate. STOP mixing
just when the mixture is smooth and lump-free.
The eggs are added next, one at a time,
scraping the bowl often to be sure the cheese is smooth. Mix in the flour,
then the sour cream. Keep the machine on low. DO NOT
OVERBEAT.
Pour in your batter into the crust making sure to scrape
out every last bit. But, before you go to the oven, I run a knife through
mine in an "S" shape to help get rid of any extra air bubbles. And, if any
float up to the top but don't break on their own, give them a little bit
of help. |
|
Fruit Topping |
Fruit is better reserved for use as a topping as its moistness will ruin a
cheesecake's creamy interior. A plain cheesecake topped with a cooled
fruit compote or fresh berries glazed with melted preserves will give you
a spectacular presentation and is so delicious. Click for a
Classic Cheesecake
Recipe with lots of topping options.
|
|
Baking, Cooling & Serving
Overbaking Problems, Such as "How
to Prevent a Cheesecake from Cracking"
|
No more soggy cheesecakes from
leaking springform pans, when baked in a waterbath. Colleen, a valued
member of baking911.com figured out a way!
Read about her new, hot tip! |
|
| WARNING:
Bacteria can grow on anything - they need only protein and
carbohydrate, plus moisture and warmth to grow quickly. Cheesecakes
contain milk and eggs products, both protein products, and high in
moisture, require refrigeration and special handling because they are
perishable. Many cheesecake recipes suggest
baking cheesecakes at low oven temperatures. My food safety research
shows that cheesecakes shouldn't be baked below 325 degrees F. In my
Baking 9-1-1 Book
(page 77), I write: " May recipes call for (baking cheesecakes) at 325
degrees F; 300 degrees F is too low, creating microbiological
concerns".
Some recipes also recommend turning off the oven when the cheesecake
is done baking and leaving it there to cool down for sometimes two
hours. It's simply not a good idea! Pathogenic bacteria
can grow in temperatures 40 - 140 degrees F, but
grow best in temperatures in the 70 to 110 degrees F zone.
baking911.com does not post recipes that use this practice.
Food safety dictates that perishable food shouldn't
be left unrefrigerated for more than two hours maximum in a room
temperature room or 1 hour in a 90 degrees F room! (this includes
total cooling and serving time). So, the combination of leaving a
cheesecake in an oven to cool down, plus additional cool down time on
the countertop, is not safe.....There's more information on
http://www.extension.iastate.edu/Publications/4H3023.pdf |
There are several schools of thought
concerning the best way to
bake a cheesecake so it won't crack, leak water and be custardy. Preferably,
bake your cheesecake in a
waterbath, especially if it doesn't contain starch such as,
cornstarch or flour.
However, cheesecakes with cornstarch or
flour do not need to be baked in a waterbath as they do not crack easily
during baking. The starch molecules will actually get in between the egg
proteins preventing them from over-coagulating. In theory, no
over-coagulating, no cracks, but it doesn't work well with large
cheesecakes. Some bakers add extra insurance to a cheesecake recipe
without starch, by simply adding 2 tablespoons of flour (works better than
cornstarch) per two pounds of creamcheese to the batter when you add the
sugar.
If you don't use a waterbath, place the
cheesecake's springform pan on an aluminum-foil lined baking sheet. This
helps to avoid leaks in the oven.
Always preheat your oven. I bake all of my
cheesecakes regardless of size or recipe in at 325 degrees F. Use an oven
thermometer, too to make sure it's accurate as ovens are notoriously
off. Cheesecakes are baked in the middle of the middle shelf in the oven
whether in a waterbath or not. Don't be tempted to open the oven door
during the first 30 to 40 minutes of baking, drafts can cause the
cheesecake to fall because of the rush of cold air into the warm oven from
the outside.
A cheesecake is done when it appears
both set and at the same time jiggle in the middle as a custard would.
There should not be wet spots or liquid areas in the center.
Remember that a cheesecake continues to
cook when it is removed from the oven. You cannot use a toothpick or cake
tester to check a custard type of recipe!!!
When
baking your cheesecake, use a conventional oven rather than a
convection oven. The forced hot air from the convection causes too
much browning and often a collapsed center. |
Make sure your cheesecake gets a gentle
cool down otherwise it can crack: cool in pan on a wire cake rack away
from drafts but near the oven as it cools to provide a warm place.
Alice Medrich likes to remove
her cheesecakes from the oven, then inverts a bowl over it to cool. Other
bakers like to turn off the oven and prop the oven door open with a wooden
spoon to reduce the heat slowly.
About 10 minutes upon removal from the
oven, loosen the cake from the edge of the pan by running the tip of a
knife or narrow spatula dipped in warm water and then dried. Use an up and
down sawing motion positioning the knife in between the edge of the cake
and the side of the pan. This allows the cake to pull away freely from the
pan as it cools so it doesn't crack.
Q:
How do you get a browned top on a cheesecake, like in those Italian
bakeries?
A: Bake
the cheesecake in a very, very hot oven (500 degrees F) for the first
ten minutes of baking, then reduce the heat to 300 degrees F. That
intense heat will brown the top, then lowering the heat will give it a
nice, slow bake that will give you an amazing creamy texture.
Cheesecake has lots of proteins in it (eggs and cheese), which like a
slow, leisurely baking rather than high heat and fast baking, which
makes cheesecake tough. |
Cool completely before refrigerating.
Chilling a warm cheesecake will trap
condensation in the cake and make it soggy.
Refrigerate preferably overnight and the
cheesecake will solidify to a perfect consistency; it takes that long. I
can't tell you how many times I unmolded a cheesecake after 4 - 6
hours (because my family get wait to get a piece) of refrigerating and it
sort of collapsed. I finally learned to keep it in the refrigerator for a
good 12 hours or more -- I found that 24 hours is best!!
After a cheesecake has chilled, gently
loosen the entire side of the cheesecake from the pan with the tip of a
knife. Then, slowly release the springform pan's collar by opening its
clamp. Carefully remove the side of the pan.
More tips
for unmolding
A cold cheesecake is easier to cut than a
warm one and will be more set. To
cut a cheesecake, make sure the knife is clean and hot, and I
would suggest using a thinner slicing knife, not a cake knife. You can dip
a sharp knife into hot water, and repeat that process every time you make
a slice. That's the best way to do it. It will get gummed up if you don't
repeat the process.
For optimum flavor, serve cheesecake at
room temperature. This takes about 1 hour after removing from the
refrigerator. Make sure the room is not too warm, otherwise the cheesecake
will soften too much. |
|
Toppings |
Although cheesecakes are certainly
delicious by themselves, a favorite topping even makes them more
appealing. I also use a topping to hide and cracks in the cheesecake. They
can be put on right after baking or when the cheesecake has chilled.
Cheesecake Topping
Recipes |
|
Gift Giving |
Gold or silver
doilies look gorgeous under cheesecakes. If you're giving them as gifts,
tie a colorful ribbon around them while they're frozen. And leaves made of
ribbon fabric make a classy nonedible garnish, as well. If desired, place
frozen cheesecake in an airtight, decorative tin. Or enclose it in
colorful cellophane and tie with ribbon. |
|
Storage |
Store the cheesecake in the refrigerator up to 7 days, tightly covered.
Baked plain (minus topping) cheesecakes freeze well for up to 2 - 3
months, if using full-fat cream cheese or 1 month for the reduced-fat
kind. If I'm going to freeze the cheesecake, I do
not put the topping on it; I put a topping on when it has thawed. If a
topping is a sour cream one, simply follow the recipe's instructions; do
not place the cheesecake back into a waterbath while baking the sour cream
topping. Before freezing, cool
completely and wrap tightly in heavy-duty foil or plastic wrap. To thaw,
place frozen cheesecake in its wrappers overnight in the refrigerator.
|
During baking, a cheesecake WITHOUT
starch, such as cornstarch or flour is more susceptible to overbaking and
cracking than one with starch. To help prevent this, bake your cheesecakes
low and slow in a
waterbath. (However,
for extra insurance, I use one for all my
cheesecake recipes.)
Many times, because a springform pan is
not made in one solid piece, it will get water in it from the waterbath. To
prevent this, bake it in a
regular pan.
(You can also envelope it in foil, but it doesn't work well consistently .) |
Here are all of the popular ways.
When baking cheesecakes or other items,
make sure the oven rack is in the center section of the oven. Unless specified
differently in the recipe. To high or low of rack placement will cause baking
problems.
Waterbath Method:
Similar to other custard desserts, such as Crème Brulee or Flan, a
waterbath, also known
as a bain-marie (French), insulates a cheesecake from the direct dry heat of the
oven. This is the method I use and recommend for best cheesecake baking for
recipes with starch, such as cornstarch or flour; the water in the bain-mairie
takes longer to heat and longer to cool than the outside air, thus maintaining a
stable temperature, ensuring that the cheesecake (which is really a type of
custard) bakes evenly. I found that cheesecakes not baked in a waterbath to be
slightly drier in their texture.
Question
from Virginia (1-23-02): I add sour cream to the top (of the cheesecake) and
bake for 5 minutes at the end. Would I keep the springform in the waterbath
while doing so? Answer: Remove the
cheesecake from the waterbath before you top and bake again. |
Some bakers place their springform
pans in larger rimmed sheet pans, place the sheet pans on the oven shelves, then
add water to a depth of about 3/8 - 1/2-inches. Ideally, use just enough water
to ensure that it has boiled off within the length of time needed for your
cheesecakes to bake.
Steam
Method: a pan is placed on the oven
floor or bottom rack while the oven preheats. Water is then poured into the pan
(about an inch or so) or ice cubes tossed in while the cheesecake is baking.
This results in steam that acts as the waterbath would. From my experience this
method is not the most dependable, but some bakers swear by it.
Straight
Oven Baking Method: no water bath or
steam is used. Best used with cheesecakes that have cornstarch or flour that
prevent the eggs from overcoagulating. Temperature usually ranges from 300 to
350 degrees F, though I like to bake mine at 325 degrees F, regardless of the
recipe. The results of the recipe depends solely upon the technique and
ingredients used in the recipe. If eggs are overbeaten, batter overmixed or the
cheesecake is overbaked, cracks will certainly result and it will rise and fall
in the oven. I personally find this method unreliable for beginners. Some
recipes come out without cracks while other may have minor to major cracks.
MORE
CHEESECAKE MAKING TIPS >>>
How to Make a Cheesecake That (Hopefully) Won't Crack & Other Problems with
Solutions >>>
|
| |